Photo of Brazilian Freestyler Monique Ferreira – Source: Pixdaus

So here you have it in writing from Executive Director Rob Butcher and USMS Board President Rob Copeland:

Dear USMS Membership,

The Executive Committee met this week and discussed the recent FINA news release. USMS does abide by FINA policies however we recognize that there is much confusion with interrupting and applying the FINA release. In response and until further suit policy clarification is provided by FINA, USMS Board President Rob Copeland issued the following statement. Additionally, the USMS Rules Committee will be meeting on May 31st as they monitor the situation, any new information made available, and the implications it could have on USMS sanctioned events.

Rob Butcher
Executive Director

To: Kathy Kasey, Rules Committee Chair
Marcia Cleveland, Long Distance Committee Chair

Date: May 20, 2009

At this point in time no suits should be listed as banned by U.S. Masters Swimming for pool or open water swimming.

While FINA has listed the 202 approved swimsuits, FINA has NOT listed the 10 suits that have been “rejected for not passing the tests of buoyancy and/or thickness” or made a ruling on the “136 swimsuits to be modified in accordance with “Dubai Charter”.” Until FINA provides the definitive list of banned swimsuits and specific actions on the 136, we should not report any suit as banned in a USMS sanctioned event.

If you hear anything from FINA in contradiction to this statement, please inform me as soon as possible. The list of FINA approved suits can be found here. The FINA press release can be found here.

Rob Copeland
President – United States Masters Swimming

This note was posted to the USMS forum by Rob Butcher himself so this is a legit statement from Masters Swimming.

I’ve started a page on the blog where you can keep up with the latest suit news at www.robaquatics.com/labels/suit_debacle.html.

I don’t know what my problem is, but I’ve been getting the most intense cramps in the backs of my legs the last 2 weeks. It happened to me at dinner in Clovis, I had to get up from the table before my leg locked at a 90 degree angle. It happened to me during a meeting yesterday at Google, that one I just had to pretend I didn’t have… easier said than done! Today I was half way though my workout and I pushed off the wall and my thighs just seized up. Not a good time! I ended up cutting my swim short because I couldn’t push off walls without reactivating my super cramps. Oh well.

The first half of my swim did feel pretty good though. I was smooth in the water and my 100 fly was really strong.

Repeat x 2
400 free
100 kick

100 fly

2 x 100 IM

float, stretch and mutter obscenities

100 cool down

1400 yards total

Tomorrow I am off to a concert in Santa Barbara so no swimming for me on Thursday, but I should be back in action on Friday. Hopefully I’ll be able to get down to Santa Maria and workout with them. So far I really like swimming with a group again.

In a glimmer of hope for the B70 faithful… I came across the following in a post from Swimming World Magazine:

In other news, U.S. Masters Swimming released the following statement regarding the impact of the FINA ruling on Masters in the U.S.

While FINA has listed the 202 approved swimsuits, FINA has NOT listed the 10 suits that have been “rejected for not passing the tests of buoyancy and/or thickness” or made a ruling on the “136 swimsuits to be modified in accordance with “Dubai Charter”.” Until FINA provides the definitive list of banned swimsuits and specific actions on the 136, we should not report any suit as banned in a USMS sanctioned event.

With FINA’s policy of not releasing banned suit information, Masters swimers in the U.S. will likely be swimming in whatever suit they want until further notice.

Source: Swimming World Magazine

I’ve got some e-mails out to see if I can get a more solid quote or a press release or something to back this statement up.

Basically USMS is saying if it has been legal it is still legal until explicitly banned from competition. I think this is the best possible answer they could have come up with given this situation. Numerous suits are still being retested and may still be legal. Also FINA refuses to state which suits are completely off the menu. I figure there are probably lawsuits and injunctions en route to this whole mess thanks to letters like this.

Stay tuned…

I spent ONE day up in Mountain View at the Googleplex away from the internet and the entire swimming world goes completely insane. FINA finally released a list of approved suits, sort of. As usual there is a lot of maybes mixed in and a lot of retesting to be done. I wish they were capable of black and white decisions that don’t have multiple caveats built into them. The big shocker is that B70 did not have a single suit approved even though some incredibly similar suits did. They were very publicly confident that they would make it past this round of testing. They’re busy appealing the decision, all the suits that failed have 30 days to do so. Originally USMS said they’d pretty much adopt FINA’s list when it was released… hundreds of masters swimmers are holding their breath to see what actually happens.

Here’s a round up of some of the news of the day…

  • The approved suit list via Swimming World Magazine

  • A letter from Dean at Blueseventy
  • The TYR Tracer Light and Rise remain legal!
  • The USMS Forum goes nuts over the news
  • So maybe the B70 passed and they failed it anyways?
  • Floswimming’s interview with B70′s CEO on the matter:

    I’m not sure where all this is going but I’ll keep the blog as up to date on it as I can.

    **I wrote this yesterday before the great suit debacle hit the internet earlier today. There is a lot of confusion and speculation surrounding B70′s complete absence from the new approved suit list from FINA. Frankly I have no idea what’s going to come of the whole situation, what masters is going to do, and by the looks of the list the fact that B70 isn’t on it is pretty fishy to me. I’ll try and keep the blog abreast of all the swimsuit drama as best I can. For what it’s worth, here’s my thoughts on the B70 swimskin having just purchased one myself 2 weeks ago.

    ***UPDATE: The blueseventy Nero Comp is legal in Masters until at least the end of 2009, it’s fate beyond that point is yet to be decided.

    I’ve been swimming in a TYR Tracer Light since March and I am enamored with it. I’ve been B70 curious because I like the company and their word of mouth in the masters community is amazing. If you were at Nationals you probably noticed that the pool deck was a veritable sea of B70′s. Lots of my friends swim in them and swear by the results. Whenever somebody talks to me about my Tracer the next question typically is “how’s it compared to the B70?” After getting that question about 400 times I decided to see for myself. I don’t know anybody else that owns both, if you do please chime in with a comment on this post, I’m very curious how other people feel about it.

    I purchased my B70 at Clovis because they were actually there with suits for me to try on. My build doesn’t fit into their general sizing and I didn’t want to make a $300+ mistake by ordering it online. The girl running their booth (Megan?) was very helpful and let me try on 2 different sizes, a 30 and a 32. The 30 was a hell of a struggle to get on. I almost gave up half way through. I managed to get the straps up over my shoulders and I walked myself back to the tent all sweaty and disheveled wondering if I was zippable. The girl from B70 took a crack at it and decided I needed to size up, this wasn’t going to happen and even if it did it would be too constrictive to actually swim in. She handed me a bigger size and after another considerable struggle I managed to get this one on me. It was still tight and not easy to zip up, but it was a little long. I managed to work it out later where I jacked the suit up higher to negate most of the length problem. Since I was wrapped in a chloroprene sausage casing with no desire to attempt to take it off I decided this was as good a time as any to finally buy one of these things. They were running a deal at nationals where you could buy the suit for $336 and get a free pair of goggles. Not a bad deal considering the $395 MSRP! Plus I figure this is my down payment on a next generation B70 in 2010 if this one is deemed illegal.

    After parting with a healthy pile of money I made my way to the warm up pool to get a feel for the suit. Now I know why so many swimming purists are pissed off, it is very floaty. It felt like the first time I put on any kind of techsuit, except I’ve been wearing them since December. I felt like I had the most float on my legs. I did a few hundred yards to get warmed up and used to the suit and then waited for the 50 fly. I raced the 50 fly in the B70 and honestly my first impression was “meh.” I didn’t like it. I felt floaty, not faster. I didn’t have that magical swimming epiphany so many other people have had in their first B70′d race. I swam a best time, but just barely. I was kind of put off on the suit so I switched back to my Tracer Light for the 200 breast with the thought that I would use the B70 in my 50 free the next day and see how it went. My freestyle felt pretty good in the suit. I made another very small improvement in my time. I figured I might as well swim the 100 fly in it as well, see what happens. I really wish I hadn’t. Me, butterfly, and my B70 don’t mix well. I felt either a bubble or water sloshing inside the suit and it was really distracting to my swim. I swam slightly slower than my time at Pacific masters Championships last month and I felt like crap at that meet and I honestly feel like the suit cost me time at Nationals. So across 3 races I was basically even with my times in the Tracer Light. I also did the open water swim in my B70 and that went well. I think the suit suits me in freestyle, but not much else. This weekend just to get a full test by swimming every stroke, I swam a 50 of each stroke at the Santa Clarita LCM meet hoping to learn to like this suit some more, but it just didn’t happen.

    The suit itself is well constructed and much more durable than I had expected. I’ve swam 7 pool events and an open water swim in it and I have no holes or trouble with seams. I really like B70, I own a B70 wetsuit and a few pairs of goggles, but their swimskins just aren’t built for a guy built like me. Even though it is very tight on me it seems to leak water when I butterfly which is not something I want to have to think about when I am sprinting.

    Here’ my thoughts on whether you should get yourself one. If you are thinner and fit within their sizing chart I believe this could be a very fast suit for you. If you’re like me and little more… we’ll call it powerfully built :)… you could run into trouble. Now that I’ve swam in a few different bodysuits I think the cut and the way it fits you is much more important than what it’s made out of. I really wish suit manufacturers would build some suits with more “masters friendly” dimensions because, well, we buy a ton of this stuff! If you have the chance to swim in a borrowed techsuit before buying one I highly recommend it. If you swim in SPMA and would fit into a 32 I’ll let you try mine out because I’m pretty sure I’m done with it.

    As it stands right now I think my B70 is in for early retirement, we’ll see what they come out with next year and I might give it a shot. In the meantime I am going back to my Tracer Light. It’s more realistically cut for a bigger guy and the suit construction is outstanding. I also think the compression in the Tracer is much more precise than in the B70. I’m 26 swims deep in my Tracer and when it finally gives out or I get bored of it, I think my next suit is going to be Tracer Rise as long as the price is reasonable (I’ve seen $400+ kinds of numbers, ouch!). I’m probably the 1 out of 10 that doesn’t like the B70 Nero, but it is what it is. I really wanted to love it, it’s just not the right suit for me.

    So in a nutshell… for me Tracer Light > B70 Nero Comp

    If you want to get yourself a B70, you can get one here.

    **UPDATE 26JUL09: I put one of my teammates in my B70 for the USMS SW Zone LCM Championships and he loved it. He’s built a lot different than me and the suit really worked well for him. He’s a 6’4″ish former power-lifter so the suit fit him a lot better and he swam some really fast times in it.

    **UPDATE 18AUG09: I’ve worn the Nero Comp in 2 more open water races and I really like it for open water. The only thing I don’t like is how often it gets mistaken for a wetsuit by people manning the finish chute. Each time I had to point out that it was NOT a wetsuit so that I could finish my race.

    **UPDATE 3SEPT09: I’ve worn this suit for all my open water races this year and I love it in open water. I just recently bought a second B70 to use when this one finally gives out. Even if it gets outlawed in Masters it will make for an excellent open water training suit for when I go float around in the ocean locally.

    I just got some video of yesterday’s meet courtesy of the McGinleys from Rosebowl.

    50 Fly – I’m the large bald guy in lane 4. I finished 1st in 30.63

    50 Breaststroke – I was 3rd in this heat with a 39.31

    I make a cameo in some videos of Patrick, but I kind of come into and out of the screen. Here’s the 50 free (29.48), and the 50 back (36.98).

    Today was my second day swimming in Santa Maria and the workout was a little more serious this time. This is good for me, but deep down I was hoping for an easy workout since I just finished my second swim meet in two weeks the day before.

    The place where everything went a little sideways for me is the set we did with fins because, well… I don’t own fins. I usually swim just as I am, maybe with a kickboard if anything, and I don’t have fins, pull buoys, snorkels, etc. Apparently now is as good a time as any to get my hands on some of this stuff! I was supposed to do 4 50′s kick and then a 100 free, but I couldn’t keep up without fins. I ended up trimming it down to 3 50′s so that I could swim a real 100 when the time came.

    200 swim
    200 kick
    200 pull

    4 x 25 fly on :45

    Repeat x 4
    4 x 50 kick on 1:00 w/ fins (I did 3 x 50 w/ no fins)
    100 free on 1:30 w/ fins (I swam w/o fins)

    easy 50

    10 x 100 w/ ~:15 rest

    easy 50 and run back to work cool down!

    3000 yards total prescribed… I swam about 2800

    This group seems to do a lot of kicking which is good. I know I need to do more kicking in my workouts, but I get really bored with it when I’m by myself. I’m glad I finally managed to drop in with these guys. Once I manage to catch up to their style of workouts I think I’ll gain a lot of benefit from it.


    I just got this picture that Tony from the SCAQ Blog took for me today. This is quite possibly the coolest picture of me ever. Generally speaking people my size shouldn’t be airborne, but turns out it’s a good look on me :)

    You can see a bigger uncropped version of the picture here.

    **UPDATE: Meet results have been posted here.


    What I lack in speed I make for in attendance :)

    This afternoon I swam at the Santa Clarita LCM meet… apparently not all of you got the memo… attendance was a little light. The crowd that was there was great though. Most of the SPMA regulars seemed to be out and we even had some from Pacific Masters and Arizona out there today too. The meet had a casual no-pressure vibe and I really enjoyed myself. The weather was good and bad. It was super nice and sunny, but it was also 100+ degrees! There was a decent breeze most of the day that took the edge off the heat, but if you were on the pool deck barefoot at all, it wasn’t a mistake you made for very long! The concrete was scorching hot and the downside to swimming all 50′s is after every race you were 50m from your shoes. Luckily we developed a system where Kathleen (Patrick’s wife) would watch the races and take pictures, videos, what have you… then she’d scoop up shoes and sandals for us and drop them back off in the shade of the timer’s tents. Best idea ever. My feet salute you :)

    I originally was scheduled for 5 events but I decided to drop one when I saw how fast the meet was going to go. This was round two for my Blueseventy suit and I wanted to give it a fair shot in 4 at least moderately rested 50′s so I let the 100 fly go. This turned out to be a pretty good idea. We jammed through the non-1500m portion of the meet in like 2 1/2 hours. I should have a B70 review or some kind of B70 vs. Tracer post out shortly (sneak peak: I like the Tracer Light better).

    My first race of the day was the 50 free. I didn’t really have a goal in this one besides making sure my time started with a 2. I was in the last heat and there were about 4 of us that seemed, at least from my vantage point during the race, to be very evenly matched. I touched at 29.48 which was good for first in my age group, and I’m not positive, but I think I was second overall. Since there’s no turn I tried to build up speed and then power my way through the race the best I could. I’ve been playing with more of a straight arm freestyle in short sprints and I’m strong enough to do this for maybe 30 meters… much more than that and it all falls apart. I’m going to keep playing with my freestyle because I feel like I’m stuck on my 50 and I think my current stroke is built more for a longer distance.

    Next up was my 50 fly. I swam a 30.something (they still haven’t posted results so I’m not sure exactly what I did) at San Luis Obispo about a month back and I wanted to hit a 30 or better again here. I focused on being long and relaxed. As much as it sucks to lose 1 wall per 50, it does give me a chance to build a really good rhythm in the water. I hit the wall at 30.63 which I believe was the best time in that event today… not exactly something I am used to saying but I like the sound of it!

    My last two events were right on top of each other. I swam the 50 back and then within 10 minutes I was back on the blocks for the 50 breast. My 50 back was ok for me but it’s really not my event. I felt like I zig zagged a little too much on the way down the pool but my actual swim felt as solid as me swimming backstroke is bound to feel. I touched at 36.98 and damn near broke my thumb in the process. I hit the pad fast and wrong. A few hours later I’m still sore but I’m ok, it works, it just doesn’t like me right now. My breaststroke felt faster than I expected. It wasn’t actually fast, but it felt good… if that makes sense. I finished in a 39.31 which really shows how bad I need turns and pull downs in breaststroke. That’s 7 seconds slower than my SCY time!

    All told, this was a good meet for me. I got myself some baseline times and got to spend the day with a good group of people. I even got a sweet pile of blue ribbons to make up for the beating I took at nationals in my age group! I don’t have them just yet, but I should have some more pictures and videos from this meet sometime soon.

    **here’s an awesome picture from today that I just got my hands on!


    Warm Up


    Sweating to death while waiting for my first event